Published on 16/04/2024 by Any Business.Com.Au

​The Business of Accounting: Should I Buy an Established Business or Start My Own?

In the dynamic field of accounting and finance, launching your own business is often an alluring prospect. The autonomy, the potential rewards, and the excitement of crafting a service from the ground up can be motivating factors. However, there's another path that's equally alluring – that of acquiring an existing accounting business.

Both routes come with distinct sets of challenges and opportunities. In this extensive guide, we'll take a deep, comprehensive look at the pros and cons of starting an accounting firm from scratch versus purchasing an established one. By dissecting these options, you'll be better equipped to make one of the most crucial decisions in your accounting career.

The Allure of the Start-up

Entrepreneurship is often the embodiment of freedom. Starting an accounting business from scratch can be an exhilarating venture, especially for the highly independent, innovative, and risk-tolerant professional. If you choose to tread this path, here's what you can expect.

The Creative Control

The first and most significant aspect of launching a start-up is the unparalleled level of control you have. From the business plan to the company culture, every decision is yours to make. This can be incredibly satisfying for many CPAs who have spent years working within existing frameworks.

Building Your Brand

With a new business, you have the unique opportunity to create an original brand identity that is genuine and relevant. Crafting a distinct brand can help your firm stand out in a saturated market and lead to better long-term customer loyalty.

Adapting to New Technologies

Starting afresh allows you to implement the latest technologies from the onset. This tech-forward approach can streamline your operations, attract tech-savvy clients, and potentially future-proof your business against obsolescence.

The Challenges of Starting Fresh

With great control comes great responsibility, and start-ups aren't without their challenges. Here are some hurdles you need to be prepared for when starting your own accounting business.

The Initial Setup

Creating a business from nothing requires a significant amount of time and capital. From registering your firm to setting up office space, purchasing software, and building a client base, the initial expenses can be daunting.

Client Acquisition

In the beginning, you will likely have no clients, meaning you have to invest in marketing and put effort into building your client list, often from scratch. It can take years to develop the kind of client base that can sustain a business.

The Risk

The failure rate for new businesses is notoriously high. In accounting, where precision and caution are paramount, taking on too much risk can jeopardize your professional reputation and financial security.

The Buyout Route: Acquiring an Existing Firm

Buying an established accounting business can offer a variety of benefits, and it's a pathway that presents a different set of opportunities and challenges compared to starting your firm.

Immediate Client Base

One of the most significant benefits of buying an existing firm is that you acquire an immediate client base. This can ensure a more stable income from the outset and provide a platform for future growth.

Reputable Foundation

An established business typically has a solid reputation in the market. When you take over, you also inherit the trust that comes with that reputation, which can be invaluable when retaining and attracting new clients.

Proven Model

An existing business also comes with a pre-existing business model that has been tested in the market. This can save you from the trial-and-error phase inherent in setting up your own venture.

Mitigating Risks When Acquiring a Business

While it's true that purchasing a business can come with less risk than starting from scratch, there are still potential pitfalls to be aware of. Here's how to proceed with caution.

Due Diligence

Thoroughly inspect all the business's financial records, operations, and liabilities to avoid any unwelcome surprises. Consulting professionals like lawyers and accountants during this phase is essential.

Cultural Alignment

Ensure that the business you're acquiring has a culture and ethos that align with yours. Mismatches in this area can lead to unhappy employees and a disrupted client experience.

Market Conditions

Consider how market trends might affect the viability and growth potential of the business you're looking to buy. An industry in decline, for example, may not be the best place to invest.

The Road Less Traveled

Between buying an established business and launching your start-up lies another option – a hybrid model of sorts. This could be buying a book of business from a retiring accountant or partnering with senior practitioners to inherit their clients.

The Decision-Making Process

Deciding between launching your start-up and buying an existing business isn't straightforward. Here are some key factors to consider that can guide you toward the right path.

Time Horizon

If you're looking for rapid growth and are willing to take on more risk, a start-up might be the better option. For a more conservative, stable outlook, buying could be ideal.

Financial Situation

Your current financial situation will heavily influence your decision. Starting a business generally requires more capital investment upfront, while purchasing can be financed through various channels.

Risk Tolerance

Consider your comfort level with risk. Starting from scratch is riskier, but success can bring greater rewards. Acquiring an existing business might be more stable but with a lower ceiling for potential growth.

Personal Goals

Your personal and professional goals should align with the path you choose. Are you looking for independence, quick growth, or stability? Understanding your ambitions is crucial in making the right decision.

Both starting an accounting business from scratch and acquiring an existing one come with their own set of opportunities and challenges. Your decision should be based on a thorough understanding of your goals, tolerance for risk, and the financial and market conditions you're operating in.

Remember, there is no one-size-fits-all approach, and what's right for one CPA may not be for the other. Take your time, do your research, and make the choice that aligns best with your career aspirations and personal philosophies.

After all, building your own accounting legacy is a significant life decision and one that deserves careful consideration. Now it's time to ask yourself – are you ready to buy in or start up?

AnyBusiness.com.au

Curtis is a leading expert in the business-for-sale industry, serving as a senior content creator at anybusiness.com.au.

With a career spanning over fifteen years, Curtis has accumulated extensive knowledge in the domain of business sales, acquisitions, and valuations. His deep understanding of market dynamics and his ability to translate complex industry jargon into accessible insights make him a trusted resource for entrepreneurs and business owners looking to buy or sell businesses.

Author profile

Related articles

Is Now a Good Time to Buy a Small Business?

24/07/2025 by AnyBusiness.com.au

For many Australians, the dream of owning a small business is about more than just profit, it's about freedom, purpose, and building something to call your own.Despite some conjecture to the contrary, in 2025, market conditions are aligning to make this an especially smart time to step in and buy an established small business.Whether you're an aspiring entrepreneur, an investor looking to diversify, or a corporate professio...